Former President Donald Trump and New York Attorney General Letitia James have for years been on a collision course, and it is now playing out in a courtroom in lower Manhattan.
Trump has long volleyed insults at James while her office investigated him and his company — an investigation that ultimately led to her filing a $250 million civil lawsuit accusing Trump and others at the Trump Organization of widespread fraud. The trial stemming from that suit got underway Monday, and Trump is there in the courtroom for opening statements.
Here's what to know about the case.
Trump, three of his children — Donald Jr., Ivanka and Eric Trump — several other company executives and the Trump Organization itself were sued in September 2022 by James. Her office accused them of perpetrating years of fraud, and vastly overrepresenting both Trump's wealth and the values of many of his properties on financial statements.
This summer, a New York appeals court dismissed allegations related to Ivanka Trump, ruling that they involved contracts from too long ago. The court did not dismiss the allegations against the company, Trump, Donald Trump Jr., or Eric Trump, allowing the claims against them to go to trial.
The Trumps and their company are accused of fraud, falsification of business records, issuing false financial statements and conspiracy, among other allegations. The attorney general has accused Trump of overstating his wealth by billions of dollars, and the value of many properties by hundreds of millions, while seeking loans. He has denied wrongdoing.
James' office is seeking $250 million and a slew of sanctions designed to severely limit the Trumps' ability to do business in New York.
Because this is a civil lawsuit, not a criminal case, there is no possibility of jail time.
Separately, Trump is facing criminal charges in a case filed in April by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg alleging 34 counts of felony falsification of business records. Trump has pleaded not guilty.
An earlier criminal tax fraud case against the Trump Organization ended with a guilty verdict last December and a plea deal by the company's former chief financial officer, Allen Weisselberg. Trump was not personally charged in that case.
Both sides presented their sides of the case during opening arguments, with Kevin Wallace leading the attorney general's team of attorneys and a host of lawyers representing the various defendants.
Wallace said prosecutors intend to demonstrate that the defendants knowingly submitted fraudulent financial statements. He said they would show that the defendants had "the intent to defraud" when falsifying the records and conspired to do so.
"The defendants knew that the statements were false. They then used them to pursue and obtain financial benefits," Wallace said.
Chris Kise, an attorney for Trump, told the judge that the statements were "true and accurate in all material respects." He said the defense has experts who can attest to the accounting practices used to arrive at the valuations. Kise added that the government's case relies on the testimony of a "serial liar," referring to former Trump attorney Michael Cohen.
Trump arrived in court for opening statements Monday morning. He had said he planned to attend at least the first day of the civil trial. Photographers were briefly allowed in the courtroom and took pictures of him sitting at the defense table alongside his attorneys:
"I'm going to Court tomorrow morning to fight for my name and reputation," he posted Sunday night on his Truth Social platform. "THIS WHOLE CASE IS SHAM!!!" he wrote, lashing out at the prosecutor and judge. "See you in Court — Monday morning."
Trump's intention was first revealed in a court filing related to a separate case: Trump's lawsuit against his former lawyer and fixer, Michael Cohen. The judge in that case noted that Trump had asked to postpone a scheduled Oct. 3 deposition because it would conflict with his plans to attend the first week of this trial.
The judge presiding over this case is Arthur Engoron, who was first appointed by then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo to the New York Supreme Court, 1st Judicial District, in 2013, after previously serving as a judge on New York City's civil court. A Democrat, he ran unopposed for the position in 2015, and is serving a 14-year term.
In April 2022, Engoron held Trump in contempt for refusing to turn over documents James had subpoenaed, and imposed a fine of $10,000 a day. He also repeatedly rejected attempts by Trump's attorneys to delay the trial date.
The upcoming proceedings are a bench trial, meaning there is no jury and Engoron will ultimately decide if the defendants are liable, as well as any damages and additional penalties.
The judge asked the attorneys involved to clear their calendars through Dec. 22. However, the trial may not last that long.
He might. Trump, Donald Trump Jr., Eric Trump and Ivanka Trump are all on preliminary witness lists submitted to the court on Sept. 27. That does not guarantee they will be called to testify.
New York state law does not allow cameras in the courtroom for most proceedings. News organizations asked the judge to allow coverage of opening statements in this case, but the judge denied that request in court on Monday. He did allow a handful of still photographers to enter the courtroom to take photos.
Ahead of the trial, on Sept. 26, Engoron issued a ruling finding that Trump overvalued the properties by hundreds of millions of dollars — and misrepresented his own worth by billions — while pursuing bank loans. Engoron's ruling was in response to a motion by James' office asking him to rule on certain allegations before the trial, which will now focus on other allegations in the lawsuit related to falsification of business records, issuing false financial statements, insurance fraud and conspiracy.
Engoron's ruling ordered the cancellation of Trump Organization business certificates and for an independent receiver to dissolve some of Trump's companies.
Trump spoke to the media after arriving at court Monday, denying the fraud allegations and saying, "What we have here is an attempt to hurt me in an election."
On his social media site, Trump has called Engoron a "political hack" and a "deranged, Trump hating judge." He has for years maligned James and the investigation, accusing her of pursuing him for political gain.
Trump even sued James in December 2021 in an effort to halt her investigation before its conclusion. On a phone call with CBS News at the time, he called James' investigation "unconstitutional" and himself an "aggrieved and innocent party." The lawsuit was later dismissed.
Letitia James, a Democrat, has won election twice as New York attorney general. She took office on Jan. 1, 2019. Before that, she served as New York City public advocate and spent almost a decade as a member of the city council.
James has a history of taking on powerful political figures. An August 2021 report compiled by independent investigators working for her office alleged a pattern of sexual harassment by then-Governor Andrew Cuomo and led to his resignation.
Her investigation in this case began in 2019 after Trump's former attorney and "fixer," Michael Cohen, gave congressional testimony in which he said Trump routinely lied about his wealth on loan, insurance and tax documents.
"Claiming that you have money that you do not have does not amount to the art of the deal, it's the art of the steal," James said at a news conference announcing the lawsuit in Sept. 2022.
In a statement released Monday ahead of the trial, she said: "For years, Donald Trump falsely inflated his net worth to enrich himself and cheat the system. ... No matter how rich or powerful you are, there are not two sets of laws for people in this country. The rule of law must apply equally to everyone, and it is my responsibility to make sure that it does."
Trump attorney Christopher Kise has argued that what the attorney general calls overvaluations are actually examples of Trump's "genius," arguing in court that Trump is "a master at finding value where others see nothing."
Engoron has not spoken publicly about the case, but he was unsparing in his pretrial fraud ruling. In the ruling, which rejected Kise's argument, he decried the "defendants' obstreperous conduct" and "their continued reliance on bogus arguments," writing that some of their arguments represented "a fantasy world, not the real world."
Graham Kates is an investigative reporter covering criminal justice, privacy issues and information security for CBS News Digital. Contact Graham at [email protected] or [email protected]
2024-12-25 13:382792 view
2024-12-25 12:342218 view
2024-12-25 12:062697 view
2024-12-25 12:05383 view
2024-12-25 11:452556 view
2024-12-25 11:321011 view
Luigi Mangione's lawyer is standing by his client's right to due process.After the 26-year-old was c
Spoiler alert! We're breaking down the pivotal first "Yellowstone" episode from Part 2 of Season 5.I
Amanda Seyfried was sick of city life.And that was why almost ten years ago, the Mean Girls actress
